Fictional demo brief · not legal advice
This is the lawyer-ready brief Kurzly prepares
A preview of issues, timeline, and evidence — sign up to explore the same flow on a sample case.
Kurzly Case Brief
Sample: Ortega v. Halvorsen Distribution — Unpaid Overtime & Retaliation (California)
- Current status
- Jun 24, 2026 · Terminated
- Client goal
- Recover unpaid wages and challenge a termination that followed a wage complaint
- Jurisdiction
- United States (California)
- Evidence
- 6 of 6 cited
- Questions
- 2 · evidence on 6 of 6 elements
- Needs a look
- 4 contested(Conflicts 2, Defenses 2)4 open(Missing 1, For client 1, Next steps 2)
- Generated
Labels like E-01 are evidence numbers. Click or tap one to see what it is.
Executive Summary
One-liner
Desired outcome
Key facts
- 2026-03-03 Manager texts: leads clock out at 2:30 and finish putaway after
- 2026-06-15 Written complaint to HR about unpaid hours
- 2026-06-22 Final warning for a June 12 "no-call/no-show" that was approved PTO
- 2026-06-24 Terminated for "attendance and reliability"
Urgent risks
- Preserve the phone and the full text thread before anything is lost
- Wage and retaliation claims have filing deadlines — raise them at the first consultation
Questions Presented
Was she left unpaid, including overtime, for work done after clocking out?
Elements & proof
Worked beyond her paid hours
Partial evidenceBadge data shows time in the building, not the work itself.
The employer directed the work
Evidence foundThe extra hours went unpaid
Partial evidenceHer complaint says so; payroll and timekeeping records would confirm it.
Analysis
- The badge log puts her on site about 10 hours a week beyond paid time, and the manager's texts direct the work after clock-out. Presence alone does not prove work — the texts carry that part.
Was the termination retaliation for her June 15 wage complaint?
Elements & proof
A protected complaint
Evidence foundAdverse action
Evidence foundA link between them
Partial evidenceTiming, the manager's "Not cool" text, and a stated reason the PTO record contradicts. Who made the decision is still unknown.
Analysis
- Nine days separate the complaint from the firing. In between, the manager wrote "Heard you went to HR. Not cool." and issued her first discipline on record.
Key contradictions & intent shifts
| Issue | Statement A | Statement B | Kurzly note |
|---|---|---|---|
The reason for the firing vs. the company's own recordsHigh Q2 | Statement A · Final written warning (June 22) Records June 12 as a no-call/no-show. | Statement B · PTO approval (May 28) Shows June 12 approved as paid time off by the same manager. | Kurzly note If June 12 was approved leave, the only incident behind the "attendance and reliability" termination did not happen as described. |
The paid hours vs. the building's own recordsHigh Q1 | Statement A · Her HR complaint email (June 15) Says her pay stubs show exactly 80 hours in every pay period — no overtime — while she works roughly 10 more hours a week. | Statement B · Badge access log & manager texts (Mar–Jun) Put her on site 48.6–52.8 hours in full weeks, with texts telling leads to clock out at 2:30 and finish putaway afterwards. | Kurzly note If the texts are authentic, the 80.00 figure records the instruction, not the hours — payroll and timekeeping records would settle it. |
Anticipated Defenses
She was fired for attendance, not for complaining.
MediumTheir basis
Rebuttal
Being in the building is not the same as working.
MediumTheir basis
Rebuttal
Statement of Facts
| Date | Event | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
Mar 3, 2026 | Told to finish work after clocking out "No OT this quarter," by text | |
May 28, 2026 | Manager approves June 12 as PTO Request #TO-88213 | |
Jun 15, 2026 | Written wage complaint to HR Unpaid hours after clock-out | |
Jun 17, 2026 | Manager: "Heard you went to HR. Not cool." Two days after the complaint | |
Jun 22, 2026 | Final written warning For a June 12 "no-call/no-show" — her first discipline | |
Jun 24, 2026 | Terminated "Attendance and reliability," nine days after the complaint |
Parties & Roles
Client
Counterparty
Others
- Brent Kowalczyk · Operations manager, her direct supervisor
Key Strengths & Risks
Strengths
- The instruction to work after clock-out is in writing, from the manager
- The stated reason for firing is contradicted by the company's own PTO record
- Complaint, warning and termination fall within nine days
Risks
- Badge data shows presence, not work — hours worked will be disputed
- No document yet shows who decided the termination
Evidence Index
| Evidence | Summary | Issues |
|---|---|---|
Access log · Jun 12, 2026 Building badge export, Mar 2–Jun 12, 2026 — about 10 hours a week on site beyond paid time
Notes: Shows presence in the building, not the work done | Related issues
| |
Text messages · Jun 17, 2026 Manager's texts, Mar–Jun 2026 — the clock-out instruction, then a reaction to the HR complaint
Notes: Exported from her phone — keep the device and the full thread | Related issues
| |
Email · Jun 15, 2026 Written complaint to HR about unpaid hours, and HR's reply that operations leadership was informed
| Related issues
| |
Scheduling record · May 28, 2026 PTO request #TO-88213 for June 12, approved by Brent Kowalczyk on May 28
| Related issues
| |
Disciplinary record · Jun 22, 2026 Final written warning for a June 12 "no-call/no-show" — her first discipline on file
| Related issues
| |
Termination letter · Jun 24, 2026 Terminated June 24 for "attendance and reliability"; no mention of the wage complaint
| Related issues
|
Open Items
Can you get the timekeeping system's edit history for your punches?
MediumIt would show whether out-punches were entered or changed to 2:30 PM, which the badge log alone cannot.
Suggested evidence
Questions for Client
Did anyone else on your shift complain, and what happened to them?
Medium
Next Steps
Preserve the phone and export the full text thread with its timestamps
HighSep 16, 2026The manager's own words are the strongest evidence and the easiest to lose
Request payroll records and the personnel file in writing
MediumSep 27, 2026Confirms the paid hours and what the file says about attendance
Prepared by the client with Kurzly, partly by AI. Not legal advice. Not covered by attorney-client privilege.